Menu of Casa Marias Restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Casa Marias Restaurant, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 1962 Coney Island Ave, offers an authentic Mexican dining experience marked by fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and a welcoming atmosphere. This local gem stands out for its well-curated menu that balances traditional Mexican staples with vibrant beverages, all served with generous portions and served promptly.

One of the true highlights of Casa Marias is their impressive beverage selection. From the crisp and refreshing Micheladas and the uniquely tropical Mango Margarita to a childhood favorite reborn as a Strawberry Milkshake to Go, the drinks complement the food masterfully. Patrons often praise the quality and authenticity of their CocaCola Mexicana and house special cocktails like the Mezcalita, with mojitos and whiskey sours rounding out a solid lineup that caters to varied palates.

Turning to the food, the Especiales De La Casa showcase the kitchen's passion and skill. The Camarones Al Mexicana, grilled shrimp sautéed with onions, tomatoes, and jalapeño, delivers a perfect burst of spicy, smoky flavor that’s both vibrant and comforting. Their Adobo Rojo, a rich red chili sauce served over tender chicken or pork with rice and beans, exemplifies the depth of Mexican culinary tradition through its aromatic complexity.

The Chiles Rellenos are a must-try — roasted poblano peppers stuffed with cheese, deep-fried, and topped with a homemade sauce, accompanied by classic rice and beans. This dish embodies the heartiness and warmth that define Casa Marias. The menu also includes crowd favorites like tortillas crafted fresh daily, which serve as the perfect base for their celebrated tacos, including tacos al pastor and carne enchilada, praised for their tender, flavorful meats.

Customer experiences further illuminate the appeal of Casa Marias. Michael Herts found the chicken fajitas flavorful with generous portions, craving the strawberry milkshake on his next visit. Eugenia V discovered a hidden treasure in their Birria, highlighting the restaurant’s commitment to regional Mexican specialties. Fernando Tlatelpa’s glowing praise of the tacos and the warmth of this family-run spot, alongside commendations for the expertly crafted frozen margaritas, speaks to the harmonious blend of quality and hospitality.

While the restaurant shines in freshness and taste, some reviews note the pricier side of Casa Marias, especially for delivery orders. A. Z. mentioned disparities in portion size and flavor balance in certain dishes but emphasized the authenticity and care in others, like the huarache, which was generously portioned and flavorful. This feedback suggests a nuanced menu where some items carry more value and satisfaction than others, indicative of the thoughtful but intricate Mexican cuisine on offer.

Overall, Casa Marias delivers an authentic, flavorful Mexican dining experience infused with genuine warmth. Their menu reflects both traditional favorites and innovative drinks, paired with attentive service. Whether indulging in the rich Adobo Rojo, savoring the grilled shrimp, or cooling off with a mango margarita, diners find themselves immersed in the vibrant flavors of Mexico right in Brooklyn.